Blog_Banner_Asset
    Homebreadcumb forward arrow iconBlogbreadcumb forward arrow iconBig Databreadcumb forward arrow iconApache Spark vs Hadoop Mapreduce – What you need to Know

Apache Spark vs Hadoop Mapreduce – What you need to Know

Last updated:
4th Sep, 2019
Views
Read Time
7 Mins
share image icon
In this article
Chevron in toc
View All
Apache Spark vs Hadoop Mapreduce – What you need to Know

Big Data is like the omnipresent Big Brother in the modern world. The ever-increasing use cases of Big Data across various industries has further given birth to numerous Big Data technologies, of which Hadoop MapReduce and Apache Spark are the most popular. While both MapReduce and Spark are open-source flagship projects developed by the Apache Software Foundation, they are the strongest contenders of each other as well. 

In this post, first, we will talk about the MapReduce and Spark frameworks, then we shall move on to discussing the key differences between them. 

What are Spark & MapReduce?

Spark is a Big Data framework specially designed for enabling fast computation. It serves as a general-purpose data processing engine that can handle different workloads, including batch, interactive, iterative and streaming. A key feature of Spark is speed – it executes in-memory computations to increase the speed of data processing. As a result, it works well on a cluster of computer nodes and allows faster processing of large datasets. 

Ads of upGrad blog

Resilient Distributed Dataset (RDD) is the primary data structure of Spark. RDD is an immutable distributed collection of objects wherein each node is divided into smaller chunks that can be computed on different nodes of a cluster. This facilitates independent data processing within a cluster.

MapReduce is an open-source framework designed for processing vast amounts of data in a parallel and distributed environment. It can process data only in batch mode. There are two primary components of Hadoop MapReduce – HDFS and YARN. 

MapReduce programming consists of two parts – Mapper and the Reducer. While the Mapper handles the task of sorting the data, the Reducer combines the sorted data and converts it into smaller fragments. 

As for the fundamental difference between these two frameworks, it is their innate approach to data processing. While MapReduce processes data by reading from and writing on the disk, Spark can do in in-memory. Thus, Spark gets an advantage over MapReduce – of speedy processing.

Explore our Popular Software Engineering Courses

But does that mean Spark is better than MapReduce? Unfortunately, the debate is not that simple. To shed more light on this issue, we will break down the differences between them point by point.

Data Processing

Spark: As we mentioned earlier, Spark is more of a hybrid and general-purpose processing framework. Through in-memory computation and processing optimization, it speeds up the data processing in real-time. It is excellent for streaming workloads, running interactive queries, and ML algorithms. However, the RDD only allows Spark to store data on the disk temporarily by writing only the vital data on the disk. So, it loads a process in the memory and retains it in the cache. This makes Spark pretty much memory-intensive.

Explore Our Software Development Free Courses

MapReduce: MapReduce is the native batch processing engine of Hadoop. It’s components (HDFS and YARN) enable smoother processing of batch data. However, since the data processing takes place in several subsequent steps, the process is quite slow. An advantage of MapReduce is that it allows for permanent storage – it stores data on disk. This makes it suitable for handling massive datasets. As soon as a task is completed, MapReduce kills its processes and hence, it can run simultaneously with other services.

Ease of Use

Spark: When it comes to ease of use, Spark takes the crown. It comes with many user-friendly APIs for Scala (native language), Java, Python, and Spark SQL. Since Spark allows streaming, batch processing, and machine learning in the same cluster, you can easily simplify the data processing infrastructure according to your needs. Also, Spark includes an interactive REPL (Read–eval–print loop) mode for running commands that offers prompt feedback to users. 

In-Demand Software Development Skills

MapReduce: Since Hadoop MapReduce is written in Java, it takes time to learn the syntax. Hence, initially, many may find it quite challenging to program. Although MapReduce lacks an interactive mode, tools like Pig and Hive make working with it a little easier. There are other tools (for instance, Xplenty) as well that can run MapReduce tasks without requiring any programming.

Fault Tolerance

Spark: Spark employs RDD and different data storage models for fault tolerance by reducing network I/O. If there is a partition loss of an RDD, the RDD will rebuild that partition from the information stored in memory. Thus, if a process crashes midway, Spark will have to start processing from the very beginning.

MapReduce: Unlike Spark, MapReduce uses the replication concept for fault tolerance through Node Manager and ResourceManager. Here, if a process fails to execute midway, MapReduce will continue from where it left off, thereby saving time.

Security

Spark: Since Spark is still at its infancy, its security factor is not highly developed.  It supports authentication via a shared secret (password authentication) sheet. As for the web UI, it can be protected through javax servlet filters. Spark’s  YARN and HDFS features allow for Kerberos authentication, HDFS file-level permissions, and encryption between nodes.

Read our Popular Articles related to Software Development

MapReduce: MapReduce is far more developed and hence, it has better security features than Spark. It enjoys all the security perks of Hadoop and can be integrated with Hadoop security projects, including Knox Gateway and Sentry. Through valid third-party vendors, organizations can even use Active Directory Kerberos and LDAP for authentication.

Cost

Although both Spark and MapReduce are open-source projects, there are certain costs you must incur for both.  For instance, Spark required large amounts of RAM to run tasks in-memory, and as it goes, RAM is costlier than hard disks. On the contrary, Hadoop is disk-oriented – while you will not need to buy expensive RAM, you will have to invest more in systems for distributing the disk I/O across multiple systems.

So, with respect to cost, it largely depends on the requirements of the organization. If an organization needs to process massive amounts of big data, Hadoop will be the cost-efficient option since buying hard disk space is way cheaper than buying expansive memory space. Moreover, MapReduce comes with a host of Hadoop-as-a-service offerings and Hadoop-based services that allow you to skip the hardware and staffing requirements. Compared to this, there are only a handful of Spark-as-a-service choices.

Compatibility

As far as compatibility goes, both Spark and MapReduce are compatible with one another. Spark can be seamlessly integrated with all the data sources and file formats supported by Hadoop. Also, both are scalable. So, Spark’s compatibility with data types and data sources is pretty much the same as that of Hadoop MapReduce. 

Ads of upGrad blog

As you can see, both Spark and MapReduce have unique features that set them apart from each other. For instance,  Spark offers real-time analytics that MapReduce lacks, whereas MapReduce comes with a file system that Spark lacks. Both frameworks are excellent in their distinct way, and both come with their unique set of advantages and disadvantages. Ultimately, the debate between Spark vs MapReduce all comes down to your specific business needs and the kind of tasks you wish to accomplish.

If you are interested to know more about Big Data, check out our Advanced Certificate Programme in Big Data from IIIT Bangalore.

Learn Software Development Courses online from the World’s top Universities. Earn Executive PG Programs, Advanced Certificate Programs or Masters Programs to fast-track your career.

Profile

upGrad

Blog Author
We are an online education platform providing industry-relevant programs for professionals, designed and delivered in collaboration with world-class faculty and businesses. Merging the latest technology, pedagogy and services, we deliver an immersive learning experience for the digital world – anytime, anywhere.
Get Free Consultation

Select Coursecaret down icon
Selectcaret down icon
By clicking 'Submit' you Agree to  
UpGrad's Terms & Conditions

Our Popular Big Data Course

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1What is the misconception about Hadoop?

Hadoop being open-source derives many misconceptions. Regardless of its ease of use, managing Hadoop’s servers could add up to the cost. Big Data management can extend the costs to INR 4 Lakh when working with features like network storage. Hadoop is not a database. It is, instead, a data warehouse where data is kept, monitored, analysed, and distributed. Another misconception about Hadoop is the difficulty of setting it up. Hadoop’s management could be daunting at higher levels; however, working with MapReduce programming at certain levels is very easy. Lastly, Hadoop’s exclusive access. Big Data is not for big companies. Small companies and businesses can use Hadoop to expedite their workflows. Also, features like Excel could contribute to bringing additional power.

2Why should you study Hadoop or Spark?

Hadoop is reasonable. Businesses can use Hadoop to store their data without worrying about the cost. Hadoop is an excellent opportunity to grab the rapidly growing data market. Also, Hadoop professionals are in huge demand in the industry right now. On the other hand, there are plenty of reasons to learn Spark. Using Spark, companies can get rid of Big Data issues. Plus, it opens the door to explore all the opportunities in the market. Spark developers are the need of business organisations who are skilled with an understanding of the technology. Compared to Hadoop, Spark’s data processing speed is extensive. Finally, earning a high figure salary as a professional with Apache Spark experience wouldn’t be difficult.

3What are the critical limitations of Apache Spark?

Apache Spark misses out on having its own file management system, making it hard to store data. To meet the requirements depends on Hadoop. Apache Spark isn’t capable of handling multiple users at once. This limits multiple users from using the platform at once. Spark’s inefficiency in working with small files is another demerit that it isn’t effective.

Explore Free Courses

Suggested Blogs

50 Must Know Big Data Interview Questions and Answers 2024: For Freshers & Experienced
6327
Introduction The demand for potential candidates is increasing rapidly in the big data technologies field. There are plenty of opportunities in this
Read More

by Mohit Soni

What is Big Data – Characteristics, Types, Benefits & Examples
184025
Lately the term ‘Big Data’ has been under the limelight, but not many people know what is big data. Businesses, governmental institutions, HCPs (Healt
Read More

by Abhinav Rai

18 Feb 2024

13 Ultimate Big Data Project Ideas & Topics for Beginners [2024]
98248
Big Data Project Ideas Big Data is an exciting subject. It helps you find patterns and results you wouldn’t have noticed otherwise. This skill
Read More

by upGrad

16 Jan 2024

Be A Big Data Analyst – Skills, Salary & Job Description
899470
In an era dominated by Big Data, one cannot imagine that the skill set and expertise of traditional Data Analysts are enough to handle the complexitie
Read More

by upGrad

16 Dec 2023

12 Exciting Hadoop Project Ideas & Topics For Beginners [2024]
20249
Hadoop Project Ideas & Topics Today, big data technologies power diverse sectors, from banking and finance, IT and telecommunication, to manufact
Read More

by Rohit Sharma

29 Nov 2023

Top 6 Exciting Data Engineering Projects & Ideas For Beginners [2024]
39511
Data Engineering Projects & Topics Data engineering is among the core branches of big data. If you’re studying to become a data engineer and want
Read More

by Rohit Sharma

21 Sep 2023

Big Data Architects Salary in India: For Freshers & Experienced [2024]
899135
Big Data – the name indicates voluminous data, which can be both structured and unstructured. Many companies collect, curate, and store data, but how
Read More

by Rohit Sharma

04 Sep 2023

Top 15 MapReduce Interview Questions and Answers [For Beginners & Experienced]
7648
Do you have an upcoming big data interview? Are you wondering what questions you’ll face regarding MapReduce in the interview? Don’t worry, we have pr
Read More

by Rohit Sharma

02 Sep 2023

12 Exciting Spark Project Ideas & Topics For Beginners [2024]
32281
What is Spark? Spark is an essential instrument in advanced analytics as it can swiftly handle all sorts of data, independent of quantity or complexi
Read More

by Rohit Sharma

29 Aug 2023

Schedule 1:1 free counsellingTalk to Career Expert
icon
footer sticky close icon